I would much rather see my overall completion percentage under each show I have watched on the plays page rather than to see the percentage of users of who rated the show highly. You can always see that data when you choose to go to show's individual page but considering the profile and plays page should be tailored to the user, I think it would be more helpful to see the percentage of the show I have completed without having to check my progress page.

I would also like to be able to sort users based on how well they rated a show.

I also think that I should be able to determine what goes in the section on my profile page called Favorite Shows, rather than have that determined by my rating. Some people might rate a show a 10, but not necessarily list that as a favorite show. I think it would be better to allow the user the option of choosing their favorites.